Safe and Smart: Making After-School Hours Work for Kids - June 1998

A r c h i v e d  I n f o r m a t i o n

Chapter 1:
The Potential of After-School Programs

We must make sure that every child has a safe and enriching place to go after school so that children can say no to drugs and alcohol and crime, and yes to reading, soccer, computers and a brighter future for themselves.

--President Clinton

Working families increasingly find it difficult to care for their children during the afternoon and early evening hours. Although over 28 million children have parents who work outside the home, many of these children do not have access to affordable, quality care during the hours before and after school.[1] To meet this demand, communities are creating quality after-school programs.

As this chapter shows, school-age children and teens who are unsupervised during the hours after school are far more likely to use alcohol, drugs, and tobacco, engage in criminal and other high-risk behaviors, receive poor grades, and drop out of school than those children who have the opportunity to benefit from constructive activities supervised by responsible adults. In a 1994 Harris poll, over one-half of teachers singled out "children who are left on their own after school" as the primary explanation for students' difficulties in class.[2]

However, there is a chronic shortage of after-school programs available to serve children. Demand for school-based after-school programs outstrips supply at a rate of about 2 to 1. Seventy-four percent of elementary and middle school parents said they would be willing to pay for such a program, yet only about 31 percent of primary school parents and 39 percent of middle school parents reported that their children actually attended an after-school program at school. [3]

The lack of affordable, accessible after-school opportunities for school-age children means that an estimated five to seven million "latchkey children" go home alone after school. About 35 percent of twelve-year-olds are left by themselves regularly while their parents are at work. [4] Millions of parents--and their children--are being shortchanged.

Quality after-school programming can fill many needs of families, children, and communities. Such programs can meet family needs for adult supervision of children during after-school hours, and they can provide children with healthy alternatives to and insulation from risk-taking and delinquent behavior. According to the YMCA of the USA, nearly 100 percent of Americans agree that it is important for children to have an after-school program that helps them develop academic and social skills in a safe and caring environment. [5]

Wellesley College's National Institute on Out-of-School Time has identified four desired outcomes for after-school programs and the children who participate in them:
  • Relationships with caring, competent, and consistent adults;
  • Access to enriching learning activities;
  • Access to safe and healthy environments; and
  • Partnerships with families, schools, and communities

Quality after-school programs can provide positive environments and enriching age-appropriate activities. School-age children attending these programs can build on what they have learned during the regular school day, explore further areas of skills and interest, and develop relationships with caring adults, all of which are factors related to their success as adults.[6] Quality after-school programs develop children's abilities so that they may grow into healthy, responsible adults.

While past research has focused on how children spend their time after school and what level of supervision is provided, current research has begun to examine the various types of after-school activities and their effects on the cognitive and emotional development of children. Researchers have identified three major functions of after-school programs: providing supervision, offering enriching experiences and positive social interaction, and improving academic achievement.[7] Different programs may focus more strongly on a particular area. More and more, practitioners and parents are turning to after-school programs as an opportunity to prevent risky behaviors in children and youth and to improve student learning. In other words, practitioners and parents want after-school programs that are safe and smart.

The after-school activities included in this report were selected because they showed evidence of success--whether empirical or anecdotal--and were identified by local, regional, and national experts as particularly innovative or promising. To date, evaluation of after-school activities has been limited. Often, the information available about a program is based on the opinions of experts instead of on formal evaluations.[8] This chapter showcases promising independent and self-reported evaluation data on after-school activities. It also indicates the critical need to fund and conduct more extensive, rigorous evaluations of after-school activities and their impact on the safety, social development, and academic achievement of children.[9]

Keeping Children on the Right Track

This period of time between the school bell and the factory whistle is a most vulnerable time for children. These are the hours when children are more likely to engage in at-risk behavior and are more vulnerable to the dangers that still exist in too many neighborhoods and communities.

--Vice President Gore

About 29 percent of all juvenile offenses occur on school days between the hours of 2:00 p.m.--when young people begin to get out of school--and 8:00 p.m. Indeed, the hour immediately following the typical time of release from school--from 3:00 p.m. to 4:00 p.m.--yielded more than twice as much violent crime as the preceding hour, from 2:00 p.m. to 3:00 p.m. (Compare 6.5 percent from 3:00 p.m. to 4:00 p.m. versus 2.8 percent from 2:00 p.m. to 3:00 p.m.).[10]

Children are also at a much greater risk of being the victim of a violent crime (e.g., murder, violent sex offense, robbery, and assault) during the hours after school. For young people, ages 6 to 17, this risk peaks at 3:00 p.m., the end of the school day. For children, ages 6 to 11, the risk declines after 3:00 p.m., but for older children and teens, ages 12 to 17, the risk remains relatively constant from 4:00 p.m. to midnight.[12]

Quality after-school programs can meet family needs by providing responsible adult supervision of children during non-school hours. By offering young people rewarding, challenging, and age-appropriate activities in a safe, structured, and positive environment, after-school programs help to reduce and prevent juvenile delinquency and to insulate children from injury and violent victimization. After-school programs give children and teenagers positive things to say "yes" to.

Preventing crime, juvenile delinquency, and violent victimization. The following studies show that quality after-school programming can have a positive impact on children and youth at risk for delinquent behaviors.

Decrease in juvenile crime

Decrease in violent victimization

Instead of locking youth up, we need to unlock their potential. We need to bring them back to their community and provide the guidance and support they need.

--Mayor Daley,
City of Chicago

Decrease in vandalism at schools

Preventing negative influences that lead to risky behaviors, such as drug, alcohol, and tobacco use. After-school programs can provide young people with positive and healthy alternatives to drug, alcohol, and tobacco use, criminal activity, and other high-risk behaviors during the peak crime hours after school.

Decrease in aggressive behavior associated with watching television.
The most frequent activity for children during non-school hours is television watching, which has been associated with increased aggressive behavior and other negative consequences.[28] For about one-half of the hours children spend watching television, they are watching by themselves or with other children. And roughly 90 percent of the time is spent watching programs that are not specifically designed for them.[29]

Enhancing Children's Academic Achievement

After-school programs not only keep children safe and out of trouble, but they also provide a prime opportunity to increase learning. Young people attending formal after-school programs spend more time in academic activities and in enrichment lessons than do their peers left unsupervised after school.[32]

Better grades and higher academic achievement. Students in after-school programs show better achievement in math, reading, and other subjects.[33] Preliminary research indicates an increase in student achievement when compared to past performance and to control groups made up of similar students not involved in the programs.

I used to hate math. It was stupid. But when we started using geometry and trigonometry to measure the trees and collect our data, I got pretty excited. Now I'm trying harder in school.

--Teen, Y.O.U. Program
Manchester, New Hampshire

Increased interest and ability in reading. After-school programs that include tutoring in reading and writing as well as reading for pleasure can increase reading achievement for students. Research indicates that reading aloud to children is the single most important activity for their future success in reading. Opportunities for students to practice reading and writing to achieve fluency increases their level of reading achievement.

Literacy development through practice and experience
After school, students experience what has been referred to as an "informal curriculum," which greatly impacts children's literacy development. When the informal curriculum exposes children to an environment rich in language and print, students show increased ability in reading and in math. Students need the opportunity to practice and develop their literacy skills through intelligent discussions with adults, storytelling, reading and listening, games, and other activities and interactions that extend learning beyond the regular school day.[44]

Quality, research-based tutoring programs, which fit well into after-school programs, produce improvements in reading achievement.[45] Tutoring can also lead to greater self-confidence in reading, increased motivation to read, and improved behavior.[46]

Decrease in amount of television watching
Studies show that children who watch excessive amounts of television perform poorly on literacy-related activities when compared to their peers.[52] Children typically learn far less from television than they do from a comparable amount of time spent reading.[53]

Unfortunately, the most common activity for children after school is television watching. After school and in the evenings, children watch, on average, about 23 hours of television each week, and teens watch about 22 hours per week.[54]

On being a latchkey kid:

Sometimes there are so many things you can't do. I can't have company or leave the house. If I talk on the phone, I can't let anyone know I'm here alone. But I really think they've figured it out, you know. Duh.

--Amy, 14

Development of new skills and interests. After-school programs often offer activities in which children would not otherwise be involved during the school day or at home. They give children the opportunity both to develop new skills and to pursue existing interests in greater depth.

Improved school attendance and reduced drop-out rate. After-school programs can help children develop greater confidence in their academic abilities and a greater interest in school, both of which have been shown to lead to improved school attendance.[58]

A parent was telling the teacher that their child was begging to go to school even though she had a fever because she was so excited about what she was doing in the after-school program.

--Sister Judy Donovan, Valley Interfaith
ISD, Brownsville, TX , an organizer with the
Industrial Areas Foundation

Turning in more and better quality homework. Most after-school programs offer some type of homework assistance, whether it is a scheduled daily homework time, one-on-one tutoring, or a homework club or center. Staffed by teachers, paraprofessionals, older students, and volunteers, participating children can draw on a variety of resources to tackle difficult homework. Also, the structure of an after-school program can make homework part of students' daily routine, which helps to explain why children in after-school programs display better work habits than their peers.[62]

I just used to hang out after school before coming to The 3:00 Project. Now I have something to do and my school work has improved!

--7th-grade student

More time on task. Some students take three to six times longer than others to learn the same thing.[66] After-school programs offer more time for learning in new, fun ways for all students, especially those who may need extra help or individualized assistance.

Reduced retention in grade and placement in special education. Some school districts, such as Chicago and Washington, D.C., are making concerted efforts to provide students at risk of non-promotion with after-school and summer extended learning opportunities. These programs give children the extra help they need to improve achievement in reading and math so that they not be kept behind.

A recent report by the National Academy of Sciences concludes that many reading disabilities are preventable. Children without literature-rich environments and strong reading instruction are much more likely to show delayed or impeded development of their reading ability. One major recommendation in the report is to increase the opportunities for children to engage in independent reading, an activity well-suited to after-school programs.[68]

Higher aspirations for the future, including intention to complete high school and to go to college. Caring adults can make a big impression on the way a child thinks about his or her future. By giving children role models and the tools they need to succeed in school, after-school programs can help children realize their full potential. Research shows that appropriate after-school programs for middle school children contribute to increasing rates of high school graduation.[72] Students who spent as little as one to four hours a week in extracurricular activities were almost 60 percent less likely to have dropped out of school by the time they were seniors than their peers who did not participate.[73]

Supporting Children's Social Development and Their Relationships with Adults and Peers

After-school programs provide opportunities for children to work and play together in a more informal setting than during the regular school day. The increased interaction with peers contributes to the development of social skills. In addition, after-school programs can help to improve children's self-discipline by setting a routine for time spent outside of school and by giving children the opportunity to make choices among various activities. Children also benefit from increased interaction with caring adults, who serve as role models and mentors.

Improved behavior in school. Research shows that children who participate in after-school programs may behave better in class, handle conflict more effectively, and cooperate more with authority figures and with their peers.

Fewer behavioral problems. Children who experience positive emotional climates in their after-school programs exhibit fewer behavioral problems at school.[76]

Handling conflicts better. Children in after-school programs can learn to handle conflicts by talking or negotiating rather than hitting and fighting.[79 ] More cooperative with adults and with peers. Children from low-income urban families who attended formal after-school programs or who went home to a parent were less likely to be identified as anti-social or headstrong than unsupervised or informally supervised children.[82] Better social skills. The after-school environment allows children to interact socially in a more relaxed atmosphere than during the regular school day. Children can develop important interpersonal skills during the out-of-school hours as they work on learning activities or join in recreation together. Research indicates that children with the opportunity to make social connections during after-school hours are more well adjusted and happier than those who do not.[85]

Improved self-confidence through development of caring relationships with adults and peers. Youth organizations have indicated that the single most important factor in the success of their programs is the relationship between participants and the adults who work with them. Research identifies a common characteristic of "resilient" children as having stable relationships with one or more caring adults.[89] Children, especially adolescents, say that they want and seek caring adults they can trust, who listen to and respect them.[90] Research shows that children need four to five hours of discussion weekly with knowledgeable adults or peers to support personal growth and development, a finding which the Boys and Girls Clubs of America have incorporated into the operation of their Educational Enhancement Sites in housing developments.[91]

We need someone to listen to us--really take it in. I don't have anybody to talk to, so when I have a problem inside, I just have to deal with it myself. I wish there would be more adults that ask questions because that shows that they care and want to know more.

--Cindy, 16

Strengthening Schools, Families, and Communities

Many existing after-school programs arose out of a need and a commitment by schools, families, employers, and community members to provide safe, enriching activities to children when they are not in school. In addressing this need, new family-school-community partnerships have formed in local communities across the country, benefitting everyone involved--especially the children.

More effective use of funding. After-school programs can help school districts save money over the long term because of decreased student retention and special education placements. Where there is a decrease in juvenile crime due to a program, communities also save resources.

Greater family and community involvement in children's learning and schools. Many after-school programs depend on and draw upon parent and community volunteers. Research shows that when families are involved in schools, students do better. We can also expect that when family and community members make an investment, however large or small, in a school-based after-school program, they will tend to be more interested and involved in their own children's learning, in the learning of all children in the program, and in the life of the school as a whole.

Increase in capacity to serve children

Increase in business support and involvement

Increase in parental involvement

Growth in children's personal sense of community

Development of community schools. Often, after-school programs involve parents, volunteers, and others in the schools. As they become involved, the schools become a center for the community. There are many models for community schools and many groups involved in their nurturing. These include the Charles Stewart Mott Foundation, the National Center for Community Education, the National Community Education Association, the Children's Aid Society, the National Center for Schools and Communities at Fordham University, the Center for Community Partnerships of the University of Pennsylvania, Beacon Schools and its expansion through the DeWitt Wallace-Reader's Digest Fund, United Way's Bridges to Success, Schools of the 21st Century, Missouri's Caring Communities, Communities in Schools, and the Institute for Educational Leadership's Community Schools Coalition. In addition, many states and local school systems have adopted the community schools model.

Replication
The Charles Stewart Mott Foundation, associated with Community Schools for more than 60 years, brings extended learning, recreation, and social activities into school buildings under the auspices of local education systems. It is estimated that 10,000 schools in the country have at one time or another adopted some aspects of this model.[105]

Parent and community involvement
The West Des Moines Community School District includes parents and community members, teachers, business people, and representatives from city government on site improvement teams that set the direction for each of the District's 15 schools. In addition, a community education advisory council conducts a needs assessment every few years to determine whether facilities and programs offered to all members of the community are still current. Due to the schools' outreach and offerings, 95 percent of parents and community volunteers flow in and out of the schools daily.[106]

Improved student performance
The Children's Aid Society has adopted a "settlement house" approach to schools in New York City, integrating school restructuring with "one-stop" social services, cultural opportunities, and recreational activities. The schools focus intensively on improving educational outcomes for children and youth by offering extended learning programs that complement the regular school day. Evaluation evidence indicates that children in these schools out perform similar students not enrolled in this type of community school model.[107]
-###-


[Introduction] [Table of Contents] [Chapter 2 What Works: Components of Exemplary After-School Programs]