A r c h i v e d  I n f o r m a t i o n

Biennial Evaluation Report - FY 93-94

Chapter 504

Federal Perkins Loan Program

(CFDA No. 84.038)

I. Program Profile

Legislation: Higher Education Act (HEA) of 1965, Title IV, Part E, as amended (20 U.S.C. 1087aa-1087hh) (expires September 30, 1997).

Purpose: To help financially needy undergraduate and graduate students meet the costs of education by providing low-interest, long-term loans through postsecondary education institutions.

Funding History

Fiscal Year Appropriation Fiscal Year Appropriation
1959 $ 39,883,000 1985 $ 161,060,000
1960 40,393,000 1986 181,830,000
1965 145,000,000 1987 188,000,000
1970 188,785,000 1988 185,736,000
1975 321,000,000 1989 183,507,000
1980 286,000,000 1990 135,129,000
1981 186,000,000 1991 156,142,000
1982 178,560,000 1992 156,000,000
1983 178,560,000 1993 168,600,000
1984 161,060,000 1994 173,000,000

II. Program Information and Analysis

Performance Indicators

An important indicator of the Perkins Loan Program's performance in assisting needy postsecondary students is the targeting of Perkins Loan funds. Table 1 shows one measure of targeting: the percentage of dependent and independent postsecondary students who received Perkins Loans by income category.1/ As shown in the top panel, 17 percent of dependent low-income students received Perkins Loans in 1990, a significantly greater

graphic omitted

1/ Income categories are defined by income quartiles: low-income students fall in the lowest quartile of the income distribution, high-income students fall in the top quartile, and middle-income students fall in the middle two quartiles of the income distribution.

Percentage than in the high-or middle-income categories. Further, while the percentage of middle-income and high-income students receiving Perkins Loans remained steady between 1987 and 1990, the percentage of low-income recipients increased over the period. Among independent students, the picture is slightly different. As shown in the bottom panel, a higher percentage of low-income independent students received Perkins Loans in 1990 than did middle-and higher-income students. However, the percentage of low-and middle-income students receiving Perkins Loans fell between 1987 and 1990, while it rose significantly among high-income independent students.

Population Targeting and Services

The Federal Perkins Loans are available to undergraduate and graduate students who attend participating postsecondary institutions and meet certain other criteria (e.g., have a high school diploma or its equivalent or have passed an examination approved by the Secretary of Education). Applicants must demonstrate financial need based on the cost of education and the ability of the student and/or the student's family to pay this cost. The calculation of need is based on a Congressionally specified formula. Final eligibility and award amounts are determined by the postsecondary institution based on the amount of funds available at the institution and the institution's aid-packaging policy.

The Federal Perkins Loan Program, with the Federal Supplemental Educational Opportunity Grant Program and the Federal Work-Study Program are collectively referred to as "Campus-Based Programs" because the institution determines which eligible students receive awards and how much they receive.

Participation: In the 1992-93 award year, the most recent year for which student information is available, 668,771 students received Federal Perkins Loans which averaged $1,333. The total amount lent was $868 million--an amount over five times greater than the appropriation. The Federal Perkins Loan funds go into a revolving fund. Loan repayments (and interest) are used to make new loans. In 1992-93, the amount of Federal Perkins loans received by students increased over the previous year when 654,214 students received Federal Perkins loans averaging $1,326 per loan.

Distribution by Sector: Institutional participation in the program has decreased slightly: In 1992-93, 2,565 institutions received program funds, while 2,826 participated in 1991-92. Of the 2,565 institutions receiving funds, 808 were public, 1,105 were private non-profit and 652 were proprietary (private for-profit) institutions (III.1).

Table 2 displays the distribution of Federal Perkins Loan funding by type of institution since 1983-84, when these data were first collected.

Table 2

Percentage Distribution of Federal Perkins Loans to Students by Control of Institution
Awad Years 1983-84 to 1992-93

Award Year Public Private Proprietary
1992-93 49.7 44.7 5.6
1991-92 50.1 44.1 5.8
1990-91 50.7 43.5 5.8
1989-90 47.8 46.6 5.6
1988-89 49.4 45.3 5.3
1987-88 48.9 45.0 6.1
1986-87 49.2 44.1 6.7
1985-86 48.9 44.7 6.4
1984-85 49.9 43.8 6.2
1983-84 49.7 43.5 6.8

Source: III.1.

Distribution by Dependency Status and Educational Level: Table 3 shows the distribution of Federal Perkins Loans by students' dependency status and level of education. In 1992-93, dependent and independent undergraduate students and graduate students comprised 57.5, 29.4, and 13.1 percent, respectively, of all Federal Perkins Loans during that year. The percentage of Federal Perkins Loans received by graduate students has decreased since 1988-89.

Table 3

Percentage Distribution of Federal Perkins Loans to Students by Dependency Status and Level of Education2/
Award Years 1983-84 to 1992-93

Award Year Undergraduates
Dependent Independent
Graduate
Students
1992-93 57.5 29.4 13.1
1991-92 57.5 29.7 12.9
1990-91 57.8 29.4 12.9
1989-90 53.0 27.4 19.6
1988-89 52.8 27.0 20.2
1987-88 56.3 25.0 18.7
1986-87 56.2 26.3 17.4
1985-86 56.6 25.4 18.0
1984-85 57.1 25.0 17.8
1983-84 58.3 24.3 17.4

2\ Numbers may not add to 100.0 due to rounding.

Source: III.l.

Distribution by Income: Tables 4 and 5 show the percentage distribution of Federal Perkins Loans in 1989-90 by the dependency status of the student and level of family income:

Table 4

Percent Distribution of Federal Perkins Awards by Dependency Status for All Students
1992-93 Award Year

Dependent Independent Graduate Students All Students
Percent Distribution of Recipients 57.5 29.4 13.1 100.0
Percent Distribution of Aid 53.8 26.3 19.9 100.0
Average Award $ 1,248 1,191 2,025 1,333

Source III.1.

Table 5

Percent Distribution of Federal Perkins Awards by Family Income for Dependent Students
1992-93 Award Year

Dependent Students
Under
$6,000
$6,000-
$11,999
$12,000-
$17,999
$18,000-
$23,999
$24,000-
$29,000
$30,000+ Total
Percent Distribution of Recipients 5.5 7.6 10.3 12.8 13.0 50.8 100.0
Percent Distribution of Aid 5.5 7.6 10.4 12.9 13.1 50.5 100.0
Average Award $ 1,248 1,242 1,256 1,261 1,262 1,241 1,248

Source: III.1

Program Administration

The Department of Education allocates funds to support Federal Perkins Loans to postsecondary education institutions based on the amount the institution expended in the 1985-86 award year, less a default penalty, plus an increase based on the school's fair share of the total appropriation for the current year. Institutions then distribute these funds to eligible students according to their own aid-packaging policy. The Federal Perkins Loans are a combination of Federal and institutional capital contributions. The institutional capital contribution must equal at least three-tenths of the Federal capital contribution.

To receive a Federal Perkins Loan, students must meet certain categorical eligibility criteria and demonstrate financial need (the cost of their attendance must exceed their expected family contribution, Pell Grant, and other financial aid received). Institutions determine the distribution of loans among eligible applicants and must give priority to those with exceptional financial need.

Beginning with the 1993-94 award year, the maximum annual loan limit is $3,000 for an undergraduate and $5,000 for a graduate or professional student, with aggregate limits of $15,000 and $30,000 respectively. These represent an increase over the prior aggregate limits of $9,000 for undergraduate students and $18,000 for undergraduate and graduate students combined. For borrowers attending an institution participating in the Expanding Lending Option (institutions with default rates less than 7.5 percent and which match the Federal Capital Contribution dollar for dollar), the maximum annual loan limit is $4,000 for an undergraduate and $6,000 for a graduate or professional student with aggregate limits of $20,000 and $40,000, respectively.

Borrowers do not pay any interest while in school and during the grace period, but pay a 5 percent annual rate of interest while the loan is in repayment.

Loans can be canceled (forgiven) for statutory reasons such as loans to borrowers serving in the military or teaching low-income or handicapped children.

Table 6

Federal Perkins Loan Program Cumulative Teacher/Military Cancellations as of June 30, 1993

Cost of Principal and Interest on
Loans Issued Before 1972 Teacher and Military Teacher Loans Issued After 1972 Military Total
Public 2 Year $5,492,290 $2,809,807 $19,996 $2,829,803
Public 4 Year 294,141,343 169,938,607 83,164 170,021,177
Private 2 Year 970,628 344,381 18,188 362,569
Private 4 Year 213,260,311 99,022,656 211,113 99,233,769
Proprietary 280,556 224,215 12,679 236,894
Total $514,145,128 $272,339,666 $345,140 $272,684,212
Institutions 1,803 1,978 275

Source: III.3.

Outcomes

At the end of FY 1990, Federal Perkins Loan funds at postsecondary institutions had a current value of $5.60 billion and cumulative defaults held by institutions totaled $737 million. Also, $747 million in defaulted loans had been assigned to the Department for collection. This figure excludes information from schools that no longer participate in the program. Loans assigned to ED are excluded from institutional default calculations (III.1).

The Federal Perkins program is set up as a revolving fund: borrowers' payments replenish the school's loan funds, making capital available for loans to other students. The GAO found that 87 percent of participating institutions had operating expenses and losses, including loan cancellations (forgiveness), that exceeded their Perkins funds' income (III.3.). GAO found that, through June 1989, cumulative operating costs (including cancellations and defaults) exceeded income by about $1.05 billion. Federal and school capital contributions have been used, in part, to make up for operating losses as well as to increase funds available for loans.

Analyses from the National Postsecondary Student Aid Study, by the Department's Planning and Evaluation Service, presented in Table 7, found that:

Table 7

Percentage of Students Participating in the Perkins Loan Program3/
1989-90 Award Year

All Type of Institution Status
2 - Yr Public 4 - Yr Public Private Prop. Full-Time Part-Time
All 4.3 0.7 5.2 9.3 5.6 7.4 0.8
Graduate 4.5 NA 3.4 6.2 2.2 9.9 0.7
Undergraduate 4.3 0.7 5.7 10.3 5.6 7.2 0.8
Dependent4/ 5.6 0.7 5.4 13.0 7.4 7.3 1.1
Income
Under $10,000 10.6 1.8 13.0 19.8 8.1 13.0 4.0
$10,000-29,000 9.0 0.8 10.3 21.8 10.3 12.1 1.3
$30,000 & Over 3.3 0.4 2.5 8.7 4.4 4.3 0.4
Independent 3.0 0.8 6.3 5.8 4.9 7.0 0.8
Income
Under $10,000 5.2 1.2 9.8 10.1 5.0 7.8 1.6
$10,000 & Over 1.9 0.6 3.8 3.7 4.8 6.1 0.5

3/A percentage of participation is for each grouping of students described by the intersecting row and column descriptors (e.g., 3.4% of graduate students attending a 4-year public institution).

4/Undergraduates only

Source: III.2

The institutional default rate is calculated by dividing the principal amount outstanding on loans in default by the principal amount of all loans that have entered repayment status. This rate excludes those loans which were assigned to the Department of Education. Loans which have not yet entered into repayment status are those in student status and first grace period. Default rate by institutional type is shown in Table 8.

Table 8

Sector Distribution of Federal Perkins Cohort Default Rate
as of June 30, 1993

(A) Borrowers who Entered Repayment Status in 1991-92 Borrower from (A) in Default on June 30, 1993 Cohort Default Rate Borrowers in Default More Than 240 Days Principal Outstanding on Loans in Default More Than 240 Days
Private 2 Year 6,144 $ 2,790 45.41 14,086 $ 11,571,254
Private 4 Year 144,840 26,622 18.38 185,377 281,739,144
Proprietary 38,805 25,180 64.89 86,604 87,750,945
Public 2 Year 25,823 12,260 47.48 47,180 36,427,024
Public 4 Year 185,733 19,829 10.68 236,011 305,743,603
Total 401,345 86,681 21.60 569,258 $723,231,970

Source: III.1.

Beginning in award year 1992-93, the Federal Perkins default rate will be calculated for cohorts instead of cumulatively.

Management Improvement Strategies

As part of the Department's quality-control program, mandatory verification continued in FY 1993 to include, along with other Federal student aid programs, the Federal Perkins Loan program. Nationally, approximately 30 percent of all financial aid applications are selected for verification. Each year, the Department requires that institutions verify those financial aid applications that have been selected for verification. Students (and parents, if dependent) are required to submit documentation for key items in the student aid application form (such as tax forms and asset estimates) for review by institutions. Verification and institutional documentation requirements reduce student misreporting in the program.

III. Sources of Information

  1. Fiscal Operations Report 1992-93, unpublished tables from Campus-Based Programs Branch, Analysis Section, Office of Student Financial Assistance, U.S. Department of Education.

  2. National Postsecondary Student Aid Study. (Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics, 1990).

  3. Perkins Student Loans: Options That Could make the Program More Financially Independent (Washington, DC: U.S. General Accounting Office, December 1991).

IV. Planned Studies

None.

V. Contacts for Further Information

Program Policy:
Susan Morgan, (202) 708-8242

Program Analysis:
Blanca Rosa Rodriquez (202) 708-8963

Program Studies:
Steve Zwillinger, (202) 401-0182

-###-
[Federal Supplemental Educational Opportunity Grant Program] [Table of Contents] [Federal Work-Study Program]